What Happens After You File a Lemon Claim?

What Happens After You File a Lemon Claim?

Navigating the murky waters of a lemon claim can be daunting for many consumers. A lemon claim is essentially a formal complaint lodged by a vehicle owner against the manufacturer of a vehicle that fails to meet quality and safety standards despite multiple repair attempts. The process doesn’t just stop at filing the claim; it unfolds in several stages, involving meticulous documentation, negotiation, and, sometimes, legal action. Below, we will demystify what happens after you file a claim, guiding you through each step of the process.

How to File a Lemon Claim

Filing a lemon claim involves a series of steps designed to address and resolve issues with a vehicle that is found to be defective and not repairable after a reasonable number of attempts. The process generally follows a structured path from identifying the problem to reaching a resolution. 

The first step is to determine if your vehicle qualifies as a “lemon.” Generally, a car is considered a lemon if it has a significant defect that affects its use, value, or safety, and the defect cannot be fixed after a reasonable number of repair attempts.

In California, you must give the manufacturer a reasonable number of opportunities to repair the vehicle before proceeding with a claim. This usually involves sending a written notification to the manufacturer, detailing the issues and the repair history, and giving them one last chance to fix the problem. The specifics of how and when to send this notification can vary, so it’s important to follow your jurisdiction’s requirements closely.

If the manufacturer is unable to fix the vehicle after a reasonable number of attempts or within the final opportunity given, you can officially file a claim. This might involve submitting a claim through a state-run arbitration program, directly with the manufacturer if they have their own arbitration process, or by preparing to take legal action.

Initial Assessment and Documentation

Once you’ve filed a lemon claim, the next step is an initial assessment by the manufacturer or authorized dealer. This typically involves a thorough review of your vehicle’s history, including all repair attempts and any communication between you and the service providers. You must meticulously document every repair attempt, including dates, descriptions of the issues, and the outcomes of each repair. This documentation serves as the backbone of your claim, providing concrete evidence to support your case.

Manufacturer’s Response

After reviewing your claim, the manufacturer will respond. The response time can vary, but manufacturers are usually required by law to respond within a certain period. The manufacturer might offer to repair the vehicle again, repurchase the vehicle, replace the car with a comparable model, or, in some cases, deny the claim. The specific response depends on the severity of the issue, the number of repair attempts, and the laws governing defective vehicles in your jurisdiction.

If the manufacturer offers a remedy that you find acceptable, such as a replacement or repurchase, the process moves towards finalizing that resolution. However, if the remedy is insufficient or the claim is denied, you may need to escalate the matter.


Many lemon laws and manufacturers’ warranties require that disputes go through arbitration before pursuing litigation. Arbitration is a dispute resolution process where an impartial third party, the arbitrator, hears both sides of the dispute and makes a decision. The arbitration process is generally faster and less expensive than going to court, and it’s designed to provide a fair resolution. However, you should be aware that in some cases, the arbitrator’s decision may be binding, meaning you cannot then take the dispute to court if you’re unsatisfied with the outcome.

Legal Action

If arbitration is not required, not successful, or not binding, and you’re still not satisfied with the manufacturer’s response, the next step may be to file a lawsuit. At this point, consulting with an attorney who specializes in lemon law is crucial. A skilled lawyer can navigate the complex legal landscape, advocate on your behalf, and help you understand your rights and the best course of action.

Filing a lawsuit can be a lengthy and expensive process, but it may be necessary to obtain a fair resolution. If your case is strong, the court may order the manufacturer to repurchase or replace the vehicle, and you may also be awarded damages, legal fees, and other compensation.


Throughout the lemon claim process, there’s always the possibility of settlement. A settlement is a mutual agreement between you and the manufacturer to resolve the dispute without further legal action. Settlements can occur at any stage of the process, and they often involve the manufacturer offering to repurchase or replace the vehicle, possibly along with additional compensation. Settlement negotiations can be complex, and having legal representation is beneficial to ensure that any agreement is in your best interest.

Move Through the Lemon Claim Process With Johnson & Buxton – The Lemon Law Guys

The journey through a lemon claim is fraught with documentation, negotiations, and possibly legal proceedings. Each step of the process, from the initial assessment to potential litigation, requires patience, thorough documentation, and, often, legal advice. The ultimate goal is to reach a fair resolution that compensates you for a vehicle that failed to meet promised standards of quality and safety. Remember; laws vary by jurisdiction, so understanding the specific lemon laws and consumer protection statutes in your area is essential for navigating this process successfully.

At Johnson & Buxton – The Lemon Law Guys, we can help you handle the entire lemon law claim process from start to finish. If you believe your vehicle may be a lemon, reach out to our skilled California lemon attorneys today to discuss how we can help you move forward through the process and receive fair compensation for your defective vehicle. 

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

Lemon Trouble?​

See if you qualify!