5 Common Lemon Law Myths Debunked

5 Common Lemon Law Myths Debunked

Lemon laws are designed to protect consumers who purchase vehicles that fail to meet standards of quality and performance. However, myths and misconceptions about these laws abound, leading to confusion and potentially preventing individuals from exercising their rights. In California, one of the states with the most robust lemon law protections in the United States, it’s particularly important to understand the facts. That’s why we’re going to debunk five common myths associated with California’s lemon law. 

Myth 1: Lemon Laws Only Apply to New Cars

One of the most pervasive myths is that lemon laws only cover new vehicles. While it’s true that new cars are often the focus of lemon law discussions, California’s law extends protections to used cars as well, provided they are still under the original manufacturer’s warranty. This means that if you purchase a used car that is still covered, you may be entitled to remedies under state regulations if the vehicle is deemed defective.

For a used vehicle to be covered under California law, it must still be under the manufacturer’s original warranty. This is a crucial point because it extends the law’s protections to a significant number of used vehicles, including:

  • Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) Vehicles: These vehicles often come with a manufacturer’s warranty, making them eligible for lemon law claims if they have persistent defects that cannot be repaired.
  • Vehicles Under New Car Warranty: Many used vehicles are sold while still under the manufacturer’s original warranty period. If defects arise during this time, the vehicle may qualify for warranty protections.

Understanding this ensures that consumers who find themselves with a defective vehicle are aware of their rights and the potential remedies available to them, which can include replacement, repurchase, or compensation for the defective vehicle.

Myth 2: You Must Have a Certain Number of Repairs Before You Can File a Claim

Many people believe that there is a specific number of times a car must be repaired before it can qualify as defective. However, California law states that a vehicle may be considered a lemon if it has a substantial defect that the manufacturer cannot fix within a reasonable number of attempts. 

The law does not specify a universal number of repairs applicable to all situations. Instead, it provides guidelines to determine what constitutes a reasonable number of attempts, which can vary based on the defect’s nature and its impact on the vehicle’s use, value, or safety. Here’s a closer look at these guidelines:

  • Safety Defects: If the defect poses a serious safety risk, fewer repair attempts may be considered reasonable. For instance, a problem that could lead to a significant risk of injury or death to the driver or passengers might require only one or two unsuccessful repair attempts to qualify.
  • Substantial Impairment: For defects that don’t necessarily pose an immediate safety risk but significantly impair the vehicle’s use, value, or safety, the state allows a somewhat greater, but still undefined, number of repair attempts.
  • Days Out of Service: The law also considers a vehicle that has been in the repair shop for more than 30 cumulative days for warranty repairs as potentially qualifying for lemon remedies, regardless of the number of repair attempts.

Therefore, even a single failed repair attempt could potentially qualify under certain circumstances, especially if it concerns a serious safety issue or leaves the vehicle out of service too long. 

Myth 3: Lemon Claims Must Be Filed Within a Year of Purchase

Another common misconception is that lemon claims must be filed within a year of the vehicle’s purchase. In reality, California’s law allows consumers to file a claim for a refund or replacement within the warranty period or “within a reasonable time after the warranty period expires,” provided the problem first occurred while the vehicle was under warranty. This flexibility ensures that consumers are not unfairly barred from seeking relief.

While the law itself does not impose a one-year limit for filing claims, it’s essential to be aware of the statute of limitations for breach of warranty claims in California. Typically, consumers have four years from the date they realize the warranty breach to file a lawsuit. This period is much longer than the one-year myth and provides a broader timeframe for taking legal action.

Myth 4: You Need to Go Through Arbitration Before Taking Legal Action

While some states may require consumers to undergo arbitration before filing a lawsuit under warranty laws, California does not mandatorily require arbitration for lemon claims. Consumers in California have the right to choose whether to pursue arbitration or go directly to court. However voluntary arbitration might be a faster, less costly option in some cases, but it’s not a prerequisite for legal action.

Myth 5: The Lemon Law Only Covers the Vehicle’s Mechanical Issues

Many assume the lemon law exclusively pertains to mechanical defects. However, California’s lemon regulation covers any defect or condition that substantially impairs the use, value, or safety of the vehicle. This can include electrical issues, software problems in modern cars, and even persistent odors that cannot be resolved with reasonable repair attempts.

Helping You Avoid Myth-stakes in Your Lemon Claim

Misunderstandings about lemon laws can prevent consumers from seeking justice when they purchase a defective vehicle. By debunking these common myths, we’re giving consumers like you accurate information, ensuring you understand your rights under California law. If you believe you have a defective car, consult with a qualified California lemon law attorney from Johnson & Buxton – The Lemon Law Guys. We can provide you with the guidance and representation you need to navigate the legal process and achieve a better outcome. Schedule your consultation with our California lemon law firm to learn more about how we can help you. 

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

Lemon Trouble?​

See if you qualify!